In spite of the terminology used to describe cars with ADAS (advanced driver-assistance system), such as Tesla’s “Full Self-Driving” software, there are no cars currently on the market with self-driving features that do not require human driver interference to prevent an accident. In a high-profile incident in 2018, during the testing of a self-driving vehicle by Uber in Arizona, a pedestrian was killed. The “safety driver” – a human driver in the vehicle that takes over control of the vehicle if the ADAS has a malfunction, was found to be negligent since they were not looking at the road when the fatal accident occurred.

The liability of the safety driver in causing the accident was obvious – the human driver was supposed to take control of the vehicle to prevent an accident, and they failed to do so. 

However, in the court ruling, not only was the safety driver found liable, but so was Uber, the vehicle, the victim, and the state of Arizona. What led to this ruling, and under the law, who is ultimately liable in a self-driving car accident? 

What Causes Self-Driving Car Accidents? 

As the above example shows, human error can still be the cause of a self-driving car accident. In cars with an ADAS system that are currently on the market, the human driver has to be ready to take control of the vehicle at any time, and if a driver is distracted, speeding, or driving under the influence, they may fail to do so in time to prevent an accident. 

Software error can also cause an accident. If a software fails to give accurate instructions to the car’s steering, braking or speed, the car can end up in a collision with another vehicle. 

Self-driving cars can be involved in accidents because of mechanical failure. Advanced driver-assistance systems rely on extensive hardware, such as mirrors and sensors. If there is a malfunction, the ADAS may not detect hazards and not direct the vehicle in time to avoid an accident. 

Car Accident Liability and the Law

Assigning blame in a self-driving car accident under current laws is complicated, because present-day tort law places the blame for a car accident on the human driver. A self-driving car accident introduces a number of other parties that could be found negligent, including the manufacturers of the car’s hardware, the companies that designed the self-driving car’s software systems, sensors and cameras, and the designers behind the integrated system that makes up the ADAS. 

As discussed earlier, statistics reveal how human error causes car accidents – such as aggressive driving, distracted driving, speeding, and drunk driving. There is also evidence of how mechanical failure can cause a vehicle to lose control and contribute to an accident. But a self-driving car operates because of the interaction of an ADAS and a human driver – a very different situation to a conventional vehicle. A recent study at Columbia University aimed to find some answers about how humans respond in their behavior with ADAS, especially the concept of moral hazard. When it comes to self-driving vehicles, human drivers may develop moral hazard by taking more risks when driving, assuming the ADAS will drive safely for them. 

A joint effort between the law and engineering departments worked on a rule to determine how fault in a self-driving car accident could be allocated amongst the at-fault parties. The researchers used game theory to describe the ways that self-driving cars, the manufacturers, human drivers, and the legal system interact in order to optimize their goals. For drivers and self-driving cars, it’s getting to their destination in the best and safest way possible; for manufacturers, it’s making a profit; and for lawmakers, it’s making safer and more efficient driving possible. 

The team at Columbia University found that a liability policy created to assign comparative fault in a self-driving car accident could influence manufacturers to develop ADAS able to drive more safely and expertly than human drivers, to overcome the complaceny human drivers may feel when behind the wheel. Lawmakers could play their part by making these developments a requirement through regulations, but also attractive for self-driving car manufacturers through tax breaks, for example.

Nevada Laws About Self-Driving Cars

Nevada is one of multiple US states that have enacted laws applying to autonomous vehicles (AVs)

AVs are legal in the state of Nevada, but the driver must have an endorsement on their driver’s license. 

Although it is unlawful to use a cell phone while driving in Nevada, it is not illegal to do so when driving an AV. 

In order to be operated, tested and/or registered in Nevada, an AV must meet certain conditions. The driver must have insurance. 

If a car is converted by a third party to an AV, the original manufacturer of the vehicle does not have liability in case of an accident

Who Can Be Assigned Fault in a Self-Driving Car Accident? 

Car Accident Law

A plaintiff in a personal injury lawsuit involving a self-driving car could sue the operator of the vehicle (human driver). In Nevada, an operator may or may not be in the vehicle, but is defined as the human that engaged the autonomous technology. The more human interference an AV requires, the more likely a claim can be made against the operator. 

If the manufacturer was responsible for installing self-driving technology in the vehicle, they could be considered liable. 

A company that converted the car to an AV or installed the self-driving technology is a possible defendant in a personal injury lawsuit. 

The creators of the AV software, sensors, cameras and other technology designed for the car to operate safely without human control.

What are Some Defenses Used in Self-Driving Car Accident Lawsuits? 

The comparative fault model described earlier could be used by the defendant in a personal injury lawsuit to reduce the damages awarded to the plaintiff. In Nevada, the courts can rule that multiple parties were at fault. If one party is found to be 51% or more at fault, they are required to pay damages, but those will be reduced by the percentage that the other party is found to be at fault. 

For example, if a pedestrian is hit by a self-driving car, the judge may assign the pedestrian 35% fault for jaywalking and wearing dark clothing at night. The driver would have to pay the pedestrian’s damages, but the amount would be reduced by 35%. 

The defendant could also claim a product misuse defense and attempt to show the plaintiff altered or tampered with the vehicle and compromised its safety. 

The increasing number of deadly car accidents across the state of Nevada is alarming. It’s essential to understand the underlying causes of these accidents to prevent them. For instance, driving under the influence of drugs or alcohol is a significant contributor to fatal car accidents in the state. Furthermore, distracted driving has been a growing concern, accounting for a significant percentage of fatal teen driving accidents. It’s crucial for victims and their families to be aware of their rights, especially when dealing with insurance claim delays or settling a car accident injury claim.

We are among the top car accident attorneys in Las Vegas, known for our dedication to achieving the best possible outcome for our clients. Our experienced team will help you claim the compensation you are entitled to. Contact us or call 702-680-1111 today for a free consultation. 

As founder of Gina Corena & Associates, she is dedicated to fighting for the rights of the people who suffer life-changing personal injuries in car, truck and motorcycle accidents as well as other types of personal injury. Gina feels fortunate to serve the Nevada community and hold wrongdoers accountable for their harm to her clients.

  • This was my first time using a lawyer, which I needed due a major car accident. They made everything simple and stress free, and I couldn’t be happier with the attentive care I received from everyone at the law office. Gresia was fantastic, and kept in touch regularly. She was professional, knowledgeable, and very kind. I would recommend them to anyone.

    - Deb Compton

  • Gina and her crew are truly amazing. They exceeded my expectations. They kept in contact with me throughout the whole time and any questions I did have They would take the time and explain everything so I would know what to expect. I would highly recommend them at any time.

    - Chris S

  • Thank you very much for the services everyone answered every single one of my calls and this firm took care of me from start to finish. Thank you so much Gina for taking on my case and assisting me I will recommend you to everyone.

    - Sayra Sánchez

  • I rarely do reviews but I want to share what an outstanding team Gina Corena has. Mahna Pourshaban did such an awesome job In helping us get our settlement, she has treated us like family since day 1 that we met her.. Me and my family want to tell u guys thank u from the bottom of our hearts.

    - The LOPEZ Family

  • Working with Gina was An amazing feeling as the client to know that my case is being handled professionally and to the best it can be ! Knowing that Gina can handle it gave me confidence and peace, 100 percent recommend Gina and her associates team !

    - Jonathan Rodriguez

  • GINA CORENA is the best attorney indeed! Thank you to her amazing team the attention to detail I received was incredible. 100% recommend to everyone!

    - Clara Maria

  • My experience with Gina Corena’s office was amazing. They were all professional and were easy to reach out to during my whole case. I’d recommend their services 10/10!!

    - Mark Surban

  • I'm really satisfied with the work these ladies provide. They’re Super reliable and Professional, Alexandra was the one that helped me with my case and she’s super nice and sweet. She made sure I was aware about all the updates with my case. Overall the work they provide to the citizens of Las Vegas is top notch. Thank you Gina Corena and associates.

    - Gil Axel

  • This is the best company I have dealt with hands down. I am super thankful with them for all the work they did on behalf of my case. The process was rather simple and very well explained from start to finish. Thank you so much Gina Corena &. Associates. Thank you Kim for assisting in my case.

    - Raidel Echavarria

  • I received nothing but top notch service from this firm not once but twice please keep up the outstanding job customer service is very important to me and your firm went above and beyond again THANK YOU

    - Freda Smith

  • Such a great law firm. This was my first time having to get a lawyer due to an auto accident and they explained all the ins and outs of my case and the process. I will definitively keep them in mind again for the future.

    -Alyssa Ortega

  • If I can give Gina’s firm 10 stars I would. They have the best customer service & most knowledgeable staff I’ve ever come across. The office is always clean and it has a lovely and positive vibe. Thank you to this amazing firm to make my experience fast and easy for me. Gina definitely knows how to care of her clients and treated me like family. I will recommended to my friends and family.

    -Cony Jordan


CALL US 24/7

Schedule A Free
Injury Consultation Below

    By contacting Gina Corena & Associates, you agree to receive emails, text messages, and phone calls regarding your legal inquiry, which may be considered advertising material.